Browse the world's most comprehensive database of hedge fund investor letters, sorted by recent quarter. Access primary source research from leading institutional managers.
Buyside Digest is not affiliated with, and does not endorse, Giverny Capital Asset Management. This analysis is provided for institutional research purposes only and is not investment advice.
SOURCE UNAVAILABLE
Fund Returns
QTD+13.7%
YTD+5.89%
Annualized+16.74%
Positioning StanceConstructive
Market CapLarge Cap
Digest Analysis
Quick Take
"Giverny Capital maintains a concentrated portfolio of quality earnings compounders despite Q2 underperformance driven by extreme market dispersion favoring momentum."
Executive Summary
Giverny Capital's portfolio returned 13.7% in Q2 2026 versus 15.2% for the S&P 500, bringing year-to-date returns to 5.89% versus 10.21% for the Index. Manager David Poppe observes extreme market dispersion, with 210 S&P 500 stocks posting negative returns while the Index gained 10.2% in the first half. The manager attributes this to momentum-chasing behavior, with investors oscillating between fear of missing AI opportunities and fear of disappointing returns from massive data center investments. Despite underperformance, Poppe maintains conviction in quality holdings like Charles Schwab, Mastercard, JP Morgan, and Progressive, which continue growing earnings at healthy rates but trade at significant discounts to the Index. The portfolio's largest positions remain AI-exposed companies Alphabet, Arista Networks, and Taiwan Semiconductor, though Poppe trimmed both Alphabet and Arista after strong appreciation made them expensive. He redeployed proceeds into undervalued financials. The manager believes the market remains a weighing machine long-term and expects earnings growth to drive returns for his concentrated portfolio of 10-15 high-quality compounders.
Unlock Full Institutional Analysis
Sign in or create a free account to unlock full commentary, extracted equity pitches, and direct outbound manager source links with your 3 quarterly credits.
Algorithmic conviction, macroeconomic posture, and risk appetite signals extracted from this quarterly letter with qualitative explanations.
Signal Matrix
Market Conviction
78%
CautiousHigh
High Conviction (78%)
The portfolio is concentrated with top 10 holdings representing 61.3% of assets and the manager names and sizes specific positions throughout the letter. He provides explicit position sizing language including Schwab as third-largest position, specific purchase prices for additions ($92 and $85 for Schwab, $205 for Progressive, mid-$330s for Kinsale), and clear catalysts with EPS growth targets. The manager states he is not inclined to change course despite underperformance and added to positions during weakness. However, the portfolio holds 15-20 positions rather than extreme concentration, and the manager acknowledges uncertainty around AI returns and trimmed expensive positions, preventing a score above 0.85.
Growth Outlook
35%
BearishBullish
Bearish (35%)
The manager acknowledges the US market has been strong for good reasons, with US earnings growth the best in the world by a wide margin. He states the market still acts like a weighing machine with stocks and earnings growing together. However, he expresses caution about momentum-chasing behavior, questions whether AI investments will deliver sufficient returns, and notes concerns about investor liquidity being drained by massive tech fundraising. The outlook is mildly positive but tempered by meaningful reservations about market dynamics and valuation extremes.
Risk Appetite
45%
DefensiveAggressive
Balanced (45%)
The portfolio remains substantially invested with top positions in Alphabet (9.7%), Arista (9.0%), and other technology leaders, indicating a risk-on tilt. However, the manager trimmed his two largest positions after they became expensive and redeployed proceeds into undervalued financials, demonstrating selective risk management. The portfolio maintains exposure to AI growth while adding to out-of-favor quality names, reflecting a balanced but slightly positive risk appetite rather than maximum long exposure.
Capital Deployment
15%
De-riskingDeploying
De-risking (15%)
The manager engaged in capital rotation during the quarter, selling 20% of Arista and 17% of Alphabet to fund additions to Schwab, Kinsale, TWFG, and Progressive. This represents redeployment of proceeds rather than net new cash being put to work or cash being raised. No cash level changes are disclosed. The activity reflects selective repositioning from expensive to undervalued names rather than meaningful net deployment or de-risking, warranting a score near neutral with a slight positive bias for the willingness to add to out-of-favor positions.
Forward Guidance
25%
CautiousExpansionary
Cautious (25%)
The manager states he is not inclined to change course and will continue to own high-quality companies being left behind alongside technology leaders. He explicitly added to Schwab, Progressive, Kinsale, and TWFG during the quarter. However, he also acknowledges that top technology positions are expensive and future returns likely will be lower, suggesting limited incremental deployment into those names. The action bias is mildly positive with selective adding to undervalued positions, but the manager is not aggressively deploying across the board.
Language Signal
20%
BearishBullish
Bearish (20%)
The letter contains balanced directional language. Bullish terms include terrific businesses, healthy earnings growth, strong positions, attractive pricing, and quality compounders. Bearish language includes weird outcomes, extreme views, momentum-chasing, itchy trigger fingers, bubble concerns, moonshot dependency, and stocks being left behind. The manager uses cautious framing around AI investment returns and market dispersion while maintaining confidence in individual holdings. The net balance leans slightly positive but is heavily qualified.
Perceived Risk
65%
Low RiskElevated
Elevated Risk (65%)
The manager identifies several specific risks with meaningful discussion. He compares current AI investments to historical infrastructure buildouts like railroads and the dotcom bubble that bankrupted early investors, explicitly questioning whether AI will deliver sufficient returns. He notes massive fundraising may drain investor liquidity, discusses extreme market dispersion and momentum-chasing creating itchy trigger fingers, and states the investment thesis depends on moonshot outcomes like curing cancer. These are identifiable, named risks discussed across multiple paragraphs, though the manager does not express alarm or predict systemic crisis.
Opportunity Density
70%
ScarceAbundant
Abundant (70%)
The manager sees selective opportunities in defined areas. He identifies multiple attractive financial stocks trading at significant discounts despite healthy earnings growth, including Schwab at 12x forward earnings versus 20x for the Index, and added to four different financial positions during the quarter. He describes some terrific companies being left behind and views them as attractively priced. However, he also notes that top technology positions are expensive with lower expected future returns, indicating the opportunity set requires selectivity rather than being broadly abundant.
Time Horizon
68%
Short-TermLong-Term
Multi-Year (68%)
The manager opens the letter emphasizing that over decades stock appreciation correlates closely with earnings growth, and states in the long run the market is a weighing machine. He discusses multi-year EPS growth expectations for holdings like Schwab (56% over two years) and Mastercard (15% annually over the next few years, same as the past 20 years). The manager is willing to hold through short-term underperformance and added to positions during weakness. However, he also discusses near-term catalysts like Progressive's buyback program and provides specific 2027 EPS estimates, indicating a 2-3 year thesis horizon rather than permanent capital or decade-plus holding periods.